Windscribe vs Mullvad: The Battle of Privacy-Conscious VPNs
The main difference between Windscribe and Mullvad is that Windscribe offers up to 15 GB of bandwidth for free users per month, with access to all the same features available to paid users.
Mullvad does not have a free plan, but its paid versions are budget friendly.
In this article, we’ll take a deep dive into Windscribe vs Mullvad and help you decide which one is the best fit for your needs. We will take a look at: Pricing, Features/Privacy Tools, User Experience, Speed, Reviews & Customer Support.
We'd like to preface this comparison by saying that both VPN services prioritize transparency and privacy. Windscribe, similar to Mullvad, remains independently-owned and self-funded.
Windscribe vs Mullvad: A Detailed Breakdown
Let's look into individual comparison points.
1. Pricing
Windscribe and Mullvad both target privacy-conscious users, but their pricing models are distinct. Windscribe offers a more flexible pricing approach, including a free plan with generous data allowances and customized paid plans. The "Build a Plan" feature lets users select locations for just $1 per location per month, allowing maximum control over costs.
Mullvad takes a straightforward approach by charging a flat rate of €5 per month, with no long-term commitments or discounts for annual subscriptions. While this may seem less competitive than Windscribe's customizable options, Mullvad’s simplicity aligns with its emphasis on transparency. Users know exactly what they are paying for and are not required to commit beyond a month.
In terms of payment flexibility, Mullvad is one of the only VPNs that accepts cash payments (by mailing it in). Windscribe also has a wide range of options but the cash option sets Mullvad apart.
2. Privacy Tools
Privacy is the core of any good VPN, and both Windscribe and Mullvad excel here, albeit with different approaches and features. Windscribe offers a robust set of privacy tools beyond just the VPN service itself. These include R.O.B.E.R.T., an advanced ad and tracker blocker that users can customize to block specific domains like social media trackers or clickbait ads. Windscribe also supports protocols such as WireGuard, OpenVPN, and IKEv2.
Mullvad includes an ad blocker in its VPN, too, but it's not as intuitive as Windscribe. The process of setting it up is quite tricky, but it does work as intended.
Both Mullvad and ExpressVPN don't require an email address to sign up—users receive an anonymous account number instead. Mullvad also uses strong encryption protocols, including WireGuard and OpenVPN, and operates with a strict no-logs policy. It even runs its own infrastructure, reducing the reliance on third parties, which adds another layer of trust and security.
3. User Experience
User experience is crucial for VPN adoption, especially for those new to online privacy tools. Windscribe’s app design is straightforward, with an intuitive interface that guides users through its various features like R.O.B.E.R.T. and Network Whitelisting.
The app is available on a wide range of platforms, including Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, and iOS. Windscribe also offers feature-rich browser extensions that complement the desktop and mobile apps well.
Mullvad, on the other hand, takes a no-nonsense approach. Its app is minimalist, mirroring its overall philosophy of simplicity and privacy. The interface is easy to navigate, but some users may find it lacks the visual appeal and user-friendly extras that Windscribe provides.
It also supports a variety of platforms, including Linux, making it an excellent choice for users who need compatibility beyond mainstream operating systems.
4. User Experience
Windscribe adds value through its community-driven support forums, detailed FAQs, and guides that make it easier for users to resolve issues independently.
Mullvad offers efficient customer support via email but lacks the community and multimedia resources that Windscribe provides, which might be a drawback for those who prefer interactive assistance.
5. Speed
Speed is often a decisive factor for VPN users, as it impacts streaming, gaming, and overall browsing performance. Windscribe provides competitive speeds thanks to its use of modern protocols like WireGuard. Its extensive server network, spread across 69 countries, gives users the flexibility to connect to the nearest or fastest server, optimizing speed without compromising security. The inclusion of split-tunneling also allows users to select which apps use the VPN, further enhancing performance.
Mullvad is renowned for its consistently high speeds, thanks in part to its focus on quality over quantity in its server network. While Mullvad does not have as many locations as Windscribe, it strategically places servers to maximize performance. It also employs WireGuard, which is known for its speed and efficiency.
For streaming, Windscribe’s features like optimized servers for Netflix and other streaming services can be a huge advantage. Mullvad, being more privacy-focused, does not market itself as a streaming-friendly VPN, which may be a limitation for some users who prioritize entertainment alongside privacy.
6. Reviews
Customer reviews and expert ratings play a significant role in assessing VPN reliability and performance. Windscribe has a large, active user base and often receives praise for its innovative features and customizable pricing.
It is also recognized for its humour-infused communication style, which resonates with a younger, privacy-savvy audience. Reviews typically highlight its robust security measures, speed, and effective ad-blocking features, but some users mention occasional connectivity issues with specific servers.
Mullvad has earned a loyal following among privacy enthusiasts and cybersecurity professionals. It frequently receives high marks for its unwavering commitment to privacy and transparency. However, some users note that its minimalistic app lacks the versatility and features found in competitors like Windscribe. Despite this, Mullvad’s reputation for consistent speeds and strong privacy policies keeps its user base satisfied.
Expert reviews for Windscribe often focus on its versatility and value for money, especially with the free plan. Mullvad, meanwhile, is frequently cited as a top pick for serious privacy seekers due to its strict no-logs policy and anonymous account system.
Conclusion
Windscribe and Mullvad are both excellent VPNs, each catering to privacy and security enthusiasts.
Windscribe’s flexible pricing, feature-rich experience, and streaming capabilities make it a versatile choice for a well-rounded VPN. Mullvad, with its flat pricing and emphasis on privacy and simplicity, is ideal for those who want a minimalistic, privacy-first approach.